In the wild, life is often described as a relentless struggle for survival, governed by instinct, competition and the basic demands of staying alive. But sometimes wildlife behaviour complicates that picture.
An elephant may remain beside the body of a dead herd member, touching and investigating the remains with its trunk. Chimpanzees have been observed staying with dead companions and displaying unusual behaviours around their bodies. Dolphins and whales have been documented carrying deceased calves. In 2018, a female Southern Resident killer whale known as J35, or Tahlequah, carried her dead newborn calf for approximately 17 days.
These behaviours raise a difficult question: can animals actually grieve?
The most scientifically responsible answer is that we still cannot know exactly what another species experiences internally. But the evidence has become increasingly difficult to dismiss.
Researchers can observe what animals do after the death of another individual. They can measure changes in behaviour, social interactions, physiology and, in some cases, cognition. What they cannot do is ask an elephant, chimpanzee or orca whether it feels sadness, understands death or experiences grief in the same subjective way a human does.
That distinction matters. It does not make the behaviour insignificant. It simply means that scientists have to be careful about where observation ends and interpretation begins.
What happens when animals encounter death?
Responses to dead members of the same species have been documented across a surprisingly wide range of animals, particularly highly social species.
Elephants are among the most frequently discussed examples. Researchers have recorded elephants approaching, touching, smelling and investigating the bodies and bones of other elephants. They may return repeatedly to remains, sometimes showing prolonged interest in them. Observations of elephants responding to dying or injured individuals have also recorded behaviours such as approaching, vocalizing and attempting to assist the individual.
Chimpanzees show their own unusual responses. In one documented case, a chimpanzee was observed using a grass stem to clean the teeth of a dead group member. Other studies have recorded chimpanzees remaining near bodies, touching them, inspecting them and displaying changes in their behaviour following a death.
Cetaceans provide some of the most striking examples. Dolphins and whales have been observed supporting or carrying dead calves, sometimes for extended periods. The behaviour is particularly difficult to interpret because it can have several possible explanations, including attachment to the calf, difficulty recognizing that the animal has died, attempts to revive it, or some form of mourning.
Tahlequah's story remains one of the most remarkable examples.
In July 2018, her newborn calf died shortly after birth. Tahlequah then carried the body for approximately 17 days. Researchers and observers followed her movements as she travelled through the waters of the Pacific Northwest. The event attracted worldwide attention because the behaviour looked so familiar to humans dealing with the death of a loved one.
Interestingly, Tahlequah was observed carrying another deceased newborn in late 2024 and early 2025. NOAA Fisheries reported that she was first seen carrying the calf on December 31, 2024, and was still carrying it when researchers observed her again on January 10, 2025.
Her behaviour is compelling, but even here scientists have to resist the temptation to turn an observation into a certainty about what she was feeling.
The problem with calling it grief
For humans, grief is an emotional response to the loss of someone with whom we have a meaningful attachment. It can involve sadness, distress, changes in appetite and sleep, withdrawal, altered routines and a long process of adapting to the absence of another individual.
Animals can display some of these behaviours. That does not automatically prove that they experience grief in exactly the same way.
This is one of the central problems in studying animal emotions.
Scientists cannot directly access another animal's subjective experience. An elephant cannot describe what it remembers when it encounters the bones of a dead companion. An orca cannot explain why it continues carrying a dead calf. A chimpanzee cannot tell researchers whether remaining beside a body represents sadness, confusion, attachment, curiosity or some combination of different states.
There is also a danger of anthropomorphism, the tendency to interpret animal behaviour through human emotional categories.
But there is an opposite danger too: assuming that because animals cannot describe their emotions in human language, they must not have meaningful emotional experiences.
Modern animal behaviour research increasingly takes animal sentience seriously. Studies of animal emotions examine behavioural and physiological indicators rather than requiring animals to communicate their internal states directly. Researchers have documented evidence relevant to emotional experiences across many species, although the strength of evidence varies considerably between animals and behaviours.
The question, therefore, is becoming less about whether animals behave exactly like humans and more about what their behaviour can legitimately tell us about their internal lives.
Why social animals respond so strongly
One pattern appears repeatedly: many of the animals that show complex responses to death are highly social.
Elephants live in intricate family groups. Killer whales maintain long-lasting social relationships and travel in closely connected pods. Chimpanzees form alliances and relationships that can persist for years. Dolphins also live within complex social networks.
For such animals, losing an individual is not necessarily just the disappearance of one member of a population.
It can change the structure of the group.
A mother can lose a calf. A young animal can lose its mother. A group can lose an experienced individual. An ally can disappear. A social relationship that has existed for years can suddenly end.
This is particularly important in elephants.
Research published in 2025 examining social disruption in elephant populations found that the death or removal of individuals can affect social cohesion, fitness, calf survival and the transmission of information. The researchers reviewed 95 peer-reviewed studies and found evidence that severe disruption can interfere with social networks and the pathways through which knowledge is transmitted.
That gives conservation another dimension.
When a poacher kills an older elephant, for example, the consequences may extend beyond the loss of one animal. The group may also lose an individual carrying knowledge about its environment, migration routes, threats and social relationships.
In other words, wildlife populations are not simply collections of interchangeable individuals.
They are societies.
Death may mean different things to different species
There is another important possibility.
Animals may not necessarily understand death in the same conceptual way humans do.
Some responses could reflect attachment to a familiar individual. Others could be attempts to revive a companion. Some could involve learning about an unfamiliar biological state. A dead body may also provide information about danger in the environment.
Researchers studying animal responses to death have pointed out that even apparently "mourning" behaviours can have several possible explanations. Carrying a dead calf, for example, may reflect maternal attachment, confusion about the calf's condition, an inability to disengage from the body, or an emotional response to the loss. We should not assume that one explanation applies to every species or every individual.
That uncertainty makes the subject more interesting, not less.
It means the scientific question is still open.
What does this mean for conservation?
Perhaps the most important implication is not whether we eventually decide to use the word "grief."
It is what we learn when we stop treating animals as biological units without social and emotional lives.
Conservation has traditionally relied heavily on measurable quantities: population size, birth rates, mortality, habitat area, genetic diversity and extinction risk.
Those measurements remain essential.
But they do not capture everything that can happen when an animal disappears.
The death of an elephant can disrupt a family network. The loss of a breeding female can alter the future of a group. Removing socially important individuals can interfere with knowledge transmission. The death of a whale calf can produce behavioural responses that persist for days or weeks.
This becomes particularly important in a world where human activity is rapidly changing wildlife environments.
Habitat destruction, poaching, pollution, fishing pressure, vessel traffic and climate change can alter not only whether animals survive, but also how their societies function.
For highly social species, conservation may therefore need to consider more than population numbers. Protecting individuals, families, social relationships and culturally transmitted knowledge can also matter.
So, do animals grieve?
We should be careful with the answer.
There is growing evidence that many animals respond to the death of socially important individuals in complex ways. Some responses resemble aspects of human mourning. Some species appear to form deep social bonds, show distress when those bonds are disrupted, and behave differently around dead or dying companions.
But science has not established that every behaviour we describe as mourning represents the same subjective experience humans call grief.
That distinction is important.
Still, perhaps we do not need animals to grieve exactly as we do before taking their emotional lives seriously.
If an elephant recognizes the body of a dead companion and repeatedly investigates it, that behaviour tells us something about the importance of that individual.
If a chimpanzee remains with a dead group member, that tells us something about its social relationships.
If an orca carries a dead calf for days, whatever the precise internal experience may be, something significant is happening in the relationship between mother and offspring.
And perhaps that is where the real lesson lies.
The boundary between human emotion and animal emotion may not be a simple wall. It may be a spectrum shaped by evolution, sociality, memory, attachment and survival.
Understanding that spectrum does not require us to pretend that animals are humans.
It requires us to take them seriously as animals.
Wildlife conservation is often presented through numbers: how many elephants remain, how many whales have been lost, how many hectares of forest are protected.
Those numbers matter.
But behind every number is an individual, and behind many individuals are families, relationships, memories and social networks.
The more we learn about those relationships, the harder it becomes to see wildlife as nothing more than statistics on a conservation report.
Perhaps the question is no longer simply whether animals grieve.
Perhaps the more useful question is this:
How much of their emotional and social lives have we yet to understand?
And if we are only beginning to understand them, we should be careful about destroying what we have not yet learned how to see.
Comments
Post a Comment